Mayor Pete’s Biggest Fan
Padlock IconThis article is only a portion of the full article. If you are already a premium subscriber please login. If you are not a premium subscriber, please subscribe for access to all of our content.

0
Published in: March-April 2021 Supplemental issue.

 

I HAVE SOMETHING TO TELL YOU:  A Memoir
by Chasten Buttigieg
Atria Books. 242 pages, $27.

 

IF Pete Buttigieg’s campaign for the Democratic presidential nomination shattered boundaries, his husband has broken another: Chasten Buttigieg has written a politician’s spouse’s memoir, essentially a recounting of their relationship and the candidate affectionately known as Mayor Pete in his bid to win the party’s top spot.

            Chasten’s book deal—I’ll use first names to avoid confusion—no doubt came in part due to his popularity on social media, in particular on Twitter, where he shared bits and pieces of information and joked about the inanities of the campaign trail. His gee-whiz style is on full display. He assures us that a discussion of “camp” is not the Susan Sontag variety and that “Dad knows a thing or two about peanut butter sandwiches” (without any irony).

            To be fair, the balancing act expected of political spouses is gravity-defying, as Chasten is aware. They’re supposed to be independent spirits, not mere appendages of their famous spouses, but can’t stand out too much lest they overshadow you-know-who. Chasten was given the added challenge of being a gay trailblazer, which explains why he went to what seem like extraordi- nary lengths to let us know how ordinary he and his husband are.

            The only trouble with this approach is that the “we’re just like everyone else” routine doesn’t always make for the most fascinating reading. I wasn’t holding out to learn, for example, that their wedding registry was at the Pottery Barn. And indeed there are those who maintain that Pete and Chasten are mainstream assimilationist sellouts. No doubt these critics would point out that in this entire book Chasten offers not one sentence of explanation for why he took his husband’s surname upon getting married. It’s a patriarchal custom that feminists warned women against long ago.

            That said, Chasten is so earnest a writer that at times he’s endearing. And much of his story does actually turn into a serious message of concern for the American people. After getting a bachelor’s degree, and after enduring one night in the hospital for severe stomach pains, he found himself deep in debt. He kept this fact from Pete, who finally came home early one day to intercept the mail and found another warning notice from collectors. Chasten’s confession of shame is genuinely moving, and he offers it as a life lesson that stoked their motivation to work toward a better future for all Americans.

           One of the funniest passages in I Have Something To Tell You is when Chasten recalls critics charging that he and Pete simply weren’t “gay” enough. The author sounds incredulous, predictably enough, but here he misses an opportunity to consider this question in a larger context. For example, where does Chasten see the fight for LGBT rights going in the next four years? There’s also scant discussion of one of the chief criticisms of the political candidate—dubbed “Mayo Pete” by detractors—for what some saw as his tone deafness on racial issues. These points are also left unexplored.

            I’ll resist making a snarky joke about the book’s title; suffice it to say that at times Chasten’s memoir feels spread a bit thin. Pete Buttigieg clearly has a long political career ahead of him, as Chasten foresees in the final pages. The publishers might have thought to hold off for a decade or so, after a couple more political campaigns had built up more experience and anecdotes. As it stands, there is only so much to tell us.
____________________________________________________

Matthew Hays is co-editor (with Tom Waugh) of the “Queer Film Classics” book series.

Share

Read More from MATTHEW HAYS